Table of Contents |
---|
一、实验设置
实验目的
- 读一个TsFile的磁盘IO代价和CPU代价的大小比较
- 了解CPU代价里有没有突出的耗时瓶颈操作
IoTDB版本
- v0.13.1
实验环境
- CPU:Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-8700 CPU @ 3.20GHz,(6核12线程)
- L1 cache 284KB, L2 cache 1536KB, L3 cache 12MB
- 内存:16G
- 硬盘:1.8T HDD /dev/sdb1 mounted on /disk
- 操作系统:Ubuntu 16.04.7 LTS
...
实验设计
分析TsFile文件结构,然后把读取TsFile的耗时步骤进行分解和分类,最后进行实验测量统计。
TsFile结构
TsFile读耗时步骤分解与分类
耗时分类 | 耗时分解 |
(A)get_chunkMetadatas | (A)1_index_read_deserialize_MagicString_FileMetadataSize |
(A)2_index_read_deserialize_IndexRootNode_MetaOffset_BloomFilter | |
(A)3_2_index_read_deserialize_IndexRootNode_exclude_to_TimeseriesMetadata_forExactGet | |
(B)load_on_disk_chunk | (B)4_data_read_deserialize_ChunkHeader |
(B)5_data_read_ChunkData | |
(C)get_pageHeader | (C)6_data_deserialize_PageHeader |
(D-1)decompress_pageData | (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray |
(D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray | |
(D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer | |
(D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer | |
(D-2)decode_pageData | (D-2)8_1_createBatchData |
(D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext | |
(D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong | |
(D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read | |
(D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot | |
(D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData |
回答实验目的1:分析A、B、C、D-1、D-2类操作耗时占比,对比B类操作(磁盘IO代价所在)和D类操作(CPU代价主要所在)耗时
回答实验目的2:分析D-1操作内部各子步骤耗时占比、D-2操作内部各子步骤耗时占比
实验结论
- 本次实验使用的人工数据集不具有代表性:其编码压缩效率过低。甚至对于值列来说,和其它编码方式相比,采用PLAIN编码的空间大小是最小的。
- 在中车ZT11529数据集上的实验结果来看:
- 真实数据集的压缩率高、磁盘数据量相对小,此时【从磁盘加载Chunk数据的耗时】小于【解压缩和解码Page数据的耗时】
- D-1步骤内部的耗时瓶颈就是子步骤7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray。注意:人工数据实验里发现另一个子步骤7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us)的占比也高,分析是因为人工数据压缩率很低,子步骤7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us)耗时相对少,从而7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us)耗时占比相对偏高。
- D-1解压缩和D-2解码的空间压缩关系和耗时关系还有待探索
- 写数据的耗时可以也测量一下
- 注意RLE编码对于浮点数是有损的
实验设置
IoTDB版本
- v0.13.1
实验环境
- CPU:Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-8700 CPU @ 3.20GHz,(6核12线程)
- L1 cache 284KB, L2 cache 1536KB, L3 cache 12MB
- 内存:16G
- 硬盘:1.8T HDD /dev/sdb1 mounted on /disk
- 操作系统:Ubuntu 16.04.7 LTS
作图和csv部分截图如下所示。
RLTsFileReadCostBench用法
(1) 用人工数据写TsFile
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar WRITE_SYN [pagePointNum] [numOfPagesInChunk] [chunksWritten] [timeEncoding] [valueDataType] [valueEncoding] [compressionType] |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“写人工数据”
pagePointNum(ppn)
:一个page内的点数numOfPagesInChunk(pic)
:一个chunk内的pages数chunksWritten(cw)
:写的chunks总数timeEncoding(te)
:时间戳列编码方式valueDataType(vt)
:值列数据类型valueEncoding(ve)
:值列编码方式compressionType(co)
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar WRITE_REAL [path_of_real_data_csv_to_write] [pagePointNum] [numOfPagesInChunk] [timeEncoding] [valueDataType] [valueEncoding] [compressionType] |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“写真实数据”
path_of_real_data_csv_to_write
:用来写TsFile的真实数据集csv地址pagePointNum(ppn)
:一个page内的点数numOfPagesInChunk(pic)
:一个chunk内的pages数timeEncoding(te)
:时间戳列编码方式valueDataType(vt)
:值列数据类型valueEncoding(ve)
:值列编码方式compressionType(co)
(3) 读实验
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar READ [path_of_tsfile_to_read] [decomposeMeasureTime] [D_decompose_each_step] (timeEncoding) |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“读数据”
path_of_tsfile_to_read
:要读取的TsFile地址decomposeMeasureTime
:FALSE
to measure the read process as a whole, in which caseD_decompose_each_step
is useless.TRUE
to measure the decomposed read process, and the decomposition granularity is controlled byD_decompose_each_step
.D_decompose_each_step
:WhendecomposeMeasureTime
isTRUE
,D_decompose_each_step=FALSE
to measure the "(D_1)decompress_pageData" and "(D_2)decode_pageData" steps without further deomposition,D_decompose_each_step=TRUE
to break down these two steps further and measure substeps inside.timeEncoding(te)
:IftimeEncoding
is not specified, TS_2DIFF will be used by default.timeEncoding
控制参数 | decomposeMeasureTime=FALSE | decomposeMeasureTime=TRUE & D_decompose_each_step=FALSE 用于分析A/B/C/D-1/D-2类操作耗时占比(&实验目标1) | |
---|---|---|---|
测量的最小单元步骤 | total_time(us) |
|
|
自动化脚本
- 输出:一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、一个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
输入:见RLTsFileReadCostBench的写数据参数和读数据参数
输出:一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、一个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
WRITE_READ_JAR_PATH
:RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址Calculator_JAR_PATH
:把若干次重复读实验结果进行平均值和百分比计算的RLRepeatReadResultAvgPercCalculator-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址FILE_NAME
:要读取的TsFile的地址decomposeMeasureTime
:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数D_decompose_each_step
:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数te
::见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数REPEAT
:读实验重复次数
输出:
REPEAT个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件
*readResult-T*csv
一个把重复读实验结果横向拼接起来的csv文件
*readResult-combined.csv
一个把写结果和读结果拼接起来的csv文件
*allResult-combined.csv
一个把读结果取平均值并且按照不同粒度统计百分比的csv文件
工具地址:
WRITE_READ_JAR_PATH
:RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址Calculator_JAR_PATH
:把若干次重复读实验结果进行平均值和百分比统计计算的RLRepeatReadResultAvgPercCalculator-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址TOOL_PATH
:用于替换脚本中变量值的自动脚本工具RLtool.sh的地址READ_SCRIPT_PATH
:RLReadExpScripts.sh的地址
写数据参数:见RLTsFileReadCostBench写数据参数
读数据参数:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数
REPEAT
:读实验重复次数
输出:不同压缩方式下的一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、REPEAT个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
)、一个把重复读实验结果横向拼接起来的csv文件(*readResult-combined.csv
)、一个把写结果和读结果拼接起来的csv文件(*allResult-combined.csv
)、一个把读结果取平均值并且按照不同粒度统计百分比的csv文件(*allResult-combined-processed.csv
其它类似,不再赘述。
实验具体结果
中车数据实验结果
改变压缩方式
RLCompressionRealExpScripts.sh
压缩方式 | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
dataset | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 13 | 13 | 13 | 13 |
timeEncoding(te) | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF |
valueDataType(vt) | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE |
valueEncoding(ve) | GORILLA | GORILLA | GORILLA | GORILLA |
compression(co) | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
totalPointNum | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 19.34862614 | 23.77741051 | 23.15641212 | 36.30773735 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 1.515139659 | 1.86007007 | 1.813184341 | 2.837062438 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 15824.16667 | 19440.275 | 18948.69 | 29684.7575 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 29684.7575 | 29684.7575 | 29684.7575 | 29684.7575 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 18221.26833 | 18221.26833 | 18221.26833 | 18221.26833 |
[2] category: (A)get ChunkStatistic->(B)load on-disk Chunk->(C)get PageStatistics->(D)load in-memory PageData | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)get_chunkMetadatas | 87316.85010000001 us - 8.19883087518919% | 100289.6416 us - 12.59103802007131% | 89466.6045 us - 11.199530364576052% | 88760.777 us - 10.335699109318087% |
[Avg&Per] (B)load_on_disk_chunk | 160699.6025 us - 15.089285299443361% | 176784.88239999997 us - 22.19476647997349% | 105802.9384 us - 13.244531050378352% | 191518.85280000002 us - 22.301305860612082% |
[Avg&Per] (C)get_pageHeader | 2436.5129999999995 us - 0.22878239411203669% | 2198.3668000000007 us - 0.27599779517870476% | 2319.9517000000005 us - 0.29041416798711567% | 3134.228800000001 us - 0.3649635223062446% |
[Avg&Per] (D_1)decompress_pageData | 356587.5454999999 us - 33.482666568996265% | 31158.160799999983 us - 3.911805656191469% | 115629.7179 us - 14.474658381255693% | 29640.983400000016 us - 3.4515277590088287% |
[Avg&Per] (D_2)decode_pageData | 457950.96670000016 us - 43.000434862259155% | 486085.0215000002 us - 61.02639204858503% | 485623.25309999986 us - 60.790866035802786% | 545723.8052999998 us - 63.54650374875476% |
SUM | 1064991.4778 us | 796516.0731000002 us | 798842.4655999999 us | 858778.6472999998 us |
[3] D_1 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us) | 1269.7615999999996 us - 0.36377892330196115% | 1808.5776999999991 us - 7.207505165727991% | 1687.9916000000003 us - 1.412377327892232% | 3197.6313 us - 41.86667970732365% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us) | 345856.23130000004 us - 99.08569249502276% | 21247.39440000001 us - 84.67466169480036% | 116100.69619999993 us - 97.14384305311928% | 2432.4552000000012 us - 31.84820675254647% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer(us) | 374.18470000000025 us - 0.10720162531460037% | 442.10720000000003 us - 1.761876157051776% | 424.26030000000026 us - 0.35498732863644405% | 421.1930000000002 us - 5.51469221169019% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer(us) | 1547.4220999999993 us - 0.443326956360674% | 1594.8989000000004 us - 6.355956982419887% | 1301.2614999999998 us - 1.0887922903520593% | 1586.372500000001 us - 20.770421328439692% |
[3] D_2 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_1_createBatchData(us) | 3430.8672 us - 0.22855030377902266% | 4174.8958 us - 0.275155541260775% | 3438.1465 us - 0.22874736939899784% | 3730.6205 us - 0.24721094086707432% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext(us) | 234016.77980000002 us - 15.589238228946503% | 236135.9462 us - 15.56305048087338% | 235278.4135 us - 15.65358490817499% | 234469.6457 us - 15.537217392727715% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong(us) | 357893.9434 us - 23.841426880277478% | 360253.1425 us - 23.743262865502565% | 358341.1524 us - 23.84121675993312% | 363063.0738 us - 24.058508247673558% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read(us) | 353821.6809 us - 23.570149451806063% | 359477.8899 us - 23.692168165422427% | 356440.4841 us - 23.714761161335133% | 355773.1939 us - 23.5754416723178% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot(us) | 223758.3096 us - 14.905861011513531% | 224938.2721 us - 14.825043539994219% | 224282.1638 us - 14.921980483485841% | 226053.6587 us - 14.979528915812129% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData(us) | 328221.5562 us - 21.864774123677403% | 332305.597 us - 21.90131940694663% | 325251.7878 us - 21.639709317671908% | 325993.7043 us - 21.602092830601723% |
补充实验
时间戳和值都使用PLAIN编码,然后改变压缩。
RLCompressionRealExpScripts.sh
压缩方式 | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
dataset | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 13 | 13 | 13 | 13 |
timeEncoding(te) | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN |
valueDataType(vt) | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE |
valueEncoding(ve) | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN |
compression(co) | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
totalPointNum | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 50.7578783 | 74.71146107 | 75.81546879 | 195.0946026 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 3.977135579 | 5.846096277 | 5.932730039 | 15.26517868 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 41639.28917 | 61236.7625 | 62145.18333 | 160003 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 160003 | 160003 | 160003 | 160003 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 |
total_time(us) | 2096685.5981 | 1244193.0404 | 1195582.1173 | 1895095.384 |
[2] category: (A)get ChunkStatistic->(B)load on-disk Chunk->(C)get PageStatistics->(D)load in-memory PageData | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)get_chunkMetadatas | 86791.3859 us - 4.1844839300349514% | 100869.9527 us - 8.731470875680406% | 99547.05960000001 us - 7.911992556094877% | 88166.6213 us - 4.659966496653105% |
[Avg&Per] (B)load_on_disk_chunk | 349328.55549999996 us - 16.84222128306944% | 452828.32 us - 39.197572537012675% | 450015.7795 us - 35.76721916082827% | 1155773.8993 us - 61.08737716190697% |
[Avg&Per] (C)get_pageHeader | 2818.293900000001 us - 0.13587875585087916% | 3913.898699999998 us - 0.3387935811871694% | 3502.114700000002 us - 0.27834780402685505% | 4450.306 us - 0.23521687180559223% |
[Avg&Per] (D_1)decompress_pageData | 1350175.8349000001 us - 65.09619618668371% | 261417.90119999985 us - 22.628768326063632% | 395144.6617 us - 31.40606698493612% | 173785.97769999996 us - 9.185299626198828% |
[Avg&Per] (D_2)decode_pageData | 285009.94010000007 us - 13.74121984436101% | 336215.7518000001 us - 29.103394680056127% | 309969.7735 us - 24.636373494113883% | 469824.3798999997 us - 24.832139843435506% |
SUM | 2074124.0103 | 1155245.8243999998 | 1258179.389 | 1892001.1841999996 |
[3] D_1 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us) | 4312.080999999998 us - 0.3365746911741179% | 10247.3701 us - 5.205625954425964% | 9355.254500000003 us - 2.648386471251286% | 33088.566800000015 us - 56.71920599957147% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us) | 1274619.9271000002 us - 99.48904214184739% | 183796.93149999995 us - 93.36815862249874% | 341381.81159999996 us - 96.64204980983628% | 21318.842899999996 us - 36.54397754446109% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer(us) | 454.68920000000026 us - 0.03549026028736633% | 659.1047999999998 us - 0.334822790636471% | 604.4583000000001 us - 0.17111658310904862% | 973.5250000000001 us - 1.6687808013713306% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer(us) | 1779.4489000000008 us - 0.1388929066911369% | 2148.4263999999994 us - 1.091392632438828% | 1902.0298000000007 us - 0.5384471358033915% | 2956.5653000000016 us - 5.068035654596102% |
[3] D_2 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_1_createBatchData(us) | 3343.3923 us - 0.259976288059772% | 3522.578 us - 0.27212097540020236% | 3458.9225 us - 0.2672966393395521% | 3730.5984 us - 0.2816327187407449% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext(us) | 232202.511 us - 18.05565768873081% | 231677.2947 us - 17.897191037883086% | 231911.8133 us - 17.921548782382853% | 237390.8697 us - 17.921263258420133% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong(us) | 254086.67 us - 19.75733129255225% | 255389.3804 us - 19.72896194244707% | 255976.5501 us - 19.78120978179259% | 261059.1494 us - 19.70804415658043% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read(us) | 241634.0221 us - 18.78903535624908% | 242640.7293 us - 18.744122040429612% | 242328.9765 us - 18.726560376256852% | 246610.5964 us - 18.6172847590372% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot(us) | 230100.908 us - 17.892240746329144% | 231053.5736 us - 17.849008259784295% | 231043.8535 us - 17.85447508020484% | 235200.0462 us - 17.755872210542634% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData(us) | 324669.8983 us - 25.24575862807894% | 330206.1447 us - 25.508595744055732% | 329318.78729999997 us - 25.448909340023306% | 340641.1962 us - 25.715902896678855% |
- 可以看到,当时间戳列和值列都使用PLAIN编码之后,压缩负责了全部的压缩率,此时D-1操作和耗时占比有了明显提高;但是也可以看到,即便如此,除了GZIP之外的压缩方式的D-1耗时占比也没有增大到60%以上,D-2解码操作仍然有不小的基础耗时
改变值列编码方式
RLValueEncodingRealExpScripts.sh
编码方式 | GORILLA | PLAIN | RLE | TS_2DIFF |
dataset | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv | /disk/rl/zc_data/ZT11529.csv |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 100 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 13 | 13 | 13 | 13 |
timeEncoding(te) | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF |
valueDataType(vt) | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE | DOUBLE |
valueEncoding(ve) | GORILLA | PLAIN | RLE | TS_2DIFF |
compression(co) | SNAPPY | SNAPPY | SNAPPY | SNAPPY |
totalPointNum | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 | 12780287 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 23.15641212 | 26.59960175 | 22.10147858 | 20.98550797 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 1.813184341 | 2.081166744 | 1.740072568 | 1.642661015 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 18948.69 | 21758.61667 | 18182.29917 | 17160.8925 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 29684.7575 | 91463.48917 | 25245.93417 | 22210.36417 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 | 11461.4625 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 18221.26833 | 80000 | 13782.445 | 10746.875 |
[2] category: (A)get ChunkStatistic->(B)load on-disk Chunk->(C)get PageStatistics->(D)load in-memory PageData | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)get_chunkMetadatas | 88753.03020000001 us - 11.21274000219672% | 97256.88870000001 us - 12.181751942467722% | 84509.5108 us - 9.498496964807579% | 86370.7961 us - 11.6687579647861% |
[Avg&Per] (B)load_on_disk_chunk | 105215.9241 us - 13.29260306229143% | 138228.6108 us - 17.313597737139155% | 139816.5536 us - 15.714765088895252% | 96826.5282 us - 13.081335047881257% |
[Avg&Per] (C)get_pageHeader | 2352.1583 us - 0.2971632563133493% | 2625.5312999999983 us - 0.328856613051254% | 3388.6254999999987 us - 0.38086658793698225% | 3159.255499999999 us - 0.4268177375109232% |
[Avg&Per] (D_1)decompress_pageData | 114457.26139999992 us - 14.460120522641777% | 182862.35910000015 us - 22.904124612107367% | 155021.76800000004 us - 17.42376424722015% | 120684.50350000002 us - 16.304565026949902% |
[Avg&Per] (D_2)decode_pageData | 480759.0216999998 us - 60.73737315655672% | 377408.39589999994 us - 47.27166909523449% | 506978.10549999995 us - 56.982107111140046% | 433147.3443000001 us - 58.51852422287182% |
SUM | 791537.3956999998 us | 798381.7858000002 us | 889714.5634 us | 740188.4276000002 |
[3] D_1 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us) | 1754.3673999999999 us - 1.6860113426598728% | 2320.3632000000002 us - 1.489795195953362% | 1825.1960999999988 us - 1.548613686329812% | 1607.3271999999997 us - 1.758246074195737% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us) | 100527.56879999992 us - 96.61067644486589% | 151532.73299999998 us - 97.29198327791244% | 113686.73430000001 us - 96.4591326329927% | 87212.82 us - 95.4016073295714% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer(us) | 431.9958999999999 us - 0.41516388607230165% | 468.2119000000003 us - 0.30061666178303303% | 474.28859999999975 us - 0.4024169332984032% | 663.3730000000002 us - 0.7256599483773118% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer(us) | 1340.373799999999 us - 1.288148326401935% | 1429.1740000000002 us - 0.9176048643511714% | 1873.7816000000007 us - 1.5898367473790769% | 1932.989900000001 us - 2.1144866478555286% |
[3] D_2 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_1_createBatchData(us) | 3348.9259 us - 0.2218271110091239% | 3442.3069 us - 0.24318767981262365% | 3466.6887 us - 0.22277034162258696% | 3338.6453 us - 0.22194982158403212% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext(us) | 235317.741 us - 15.587043790733997% | 244839.8323 us - 17.29713023052909% | 239308.8755 us - 15.37805224577913% | 240223.005 us - 15.969786637750962% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong(us) | 361562.5392 us - 23.949282819264262% | 363364.4154 us - 25.67050285597614% | 362143.5815 us - 23.271443255687238% | 357833.1113 us - 23.788389623148674% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read(us) | 356325.4946 us - 23.602389962111484% | 241625.5526 us - 17.07005192367858% | 396438.5566 us - 25.475247513902037% | 335421.7093 us - 22.298501890735768% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot(us) | 225554.2633 us - 14.940327764084076% | 232364.86419999998 us - 16.415814695306036% | 224510.63450000001 us - 14.4271133273284% | 230332.4743 us - 15.312273986066641% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData(us) | 327591.9399 us - 21.699128552797042% | 329856.9807 us - 23.30331261469754% | 330303.223 us - 21.225373315680617% | 337085.3345 us - 22.409098040713936% |
人工数据实验结果
改变压缩方式
RLCompressionSynExpScripts.sh
压缩方式 | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
dataset | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
timeEncoding(te) | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF |
valueDataType(vt) | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 |
valueEncoding(ve) | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN |
compression(co) | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
totalPointNum | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 767.1312866 | 770.8444319 | 767.9423904 | 781.4226151 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 76.71300761 | 77.08436436 | 76.7941264 | 78.14216614 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 80375.41867 | 80764.81444 | 80460.47789 | 81874 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 81874 | 81874 | 81874 | 81874 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 |
[2] category: (A)get ChunkStatistic->(B)load on-disk Chunk->(C)get PageStatistics->(D)load in-memory PageData | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)get_chunkMetadatas | 101654.7566 us - 0.9318259204986696% | 86735.1136 us - 1.1689451651044902% | 82918.49919999999 us - 1.0656107165107132% | 93896.1409 us - 1.2531889263513831% |
[Avg&Per] (B)load_on_disk_chunk | 5949593.8917000005 us - 54.53739687304131% | 4849630.197000001 us - 65.35936296194448% | 5086618.179 us - 65.36966894765757% | 4851386.484999999 us - 64.74924062031137% |
[Avg&Per] (C)get_pageHeader | 6613.381399999991 us - 0.060622054656159316% | 7120.158900000014 us - 0.09595969816001626% | 7692.346500000014 us - 0.09885667184764595% | 7605.696300000007 us - 0.10150975630087579% |
[Avg&Per] (D_1)decompress_pageData | 2859428.0031000106 us - 26.211160404158996% | 521804.2723000004 us - 7.032452670194604% | 605202.8143000009 us - 7.777644443672276% | 498170.42259999976 us - 6.648853201570805% |
[Avg&Per] (D_2)decode_pageData | 1991910.319299996 us - 18.25899474764487% | 1954657.4198999994 us - 26.343279504596413% | 1998880.5966999987 us - 25.68821922031179% | 2041517.9070999995 us - 27.247207495465567% |
[3] D_1 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us) | 65952.37819999998 us - 2.5136549346918415% | 108809.34350000018 us - 59.6896105506002% | 108132.35939999981 us - 43.622622294156905% | 110765.11740000003 us - 63.813731447511664% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us) | 2554687.926599999 us - 97.36728361519128% | 68904.38600000006 us - 37.79892271446546% | 135345.91170000008 us - 54.601079805416944% | 57547.215800000035 us - 33.15396273496119% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer(us) | 811.8335000000624 us - 0.03094155721322126% | 1239.949800000022 us - 0.680200047933345% | 1184.7460000000272 us - 0.47794876167766753% | 1229.1439000000355 us - 0.7081314098345313% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer(us) | 2312.0582000000422 us - 0.08811989290364733% | 3338.2513999999974 us - 1.8312666870009688% | 3218.3657999999955 us - 1.29834913874849% | 4034.201500000018 us - 2.3241744076926314% |
[3] D_2 compare each step inside | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_1_createBatchData(us) | 5384.7852 us - 0.053292019060348375% | 5848.7599 us - 0.05759123169122766% | 5913.4963 us - 0.058362326692940975% | 6019.3023 us - 0.05943520403215091% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext(us) | 1859842.2956 us - 18.406444711361424% | 1862234.7849 us - 18.336946086748988% | 1864092.3926 us - 18.397368271414525% | 1857778.6739 us - 18.343895858133802% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong(us) | 2074757.7936 us - 20.533415498567617% | 2084700.4377 us - 20.527508047369906% | 2063043.8916 us - 20.360888969091857% | 2069930.4964 us - 20.43870456313607% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read(us) | 1876012.952 us - 18.56648209392724% | 1881471.5433999998 us - 18.526365490982297% | 1877809.2412 us - 18.532744562964893% | 1876843.1276 us - 18.53214021585961% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot(us) | 1780379.6374 us - 17.620020492363725% | 1780782.3133 us - 17.534904586680103% | 1781949.2049 us - 17.586668929952697% | 1780599.5789 us - 17.5818216126948% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData(us) | 2507922.0072 us - 24.82034518471963% | 2540605.1784 us - 25.016684556527476% | 2539577.912 us - 25.063966939883077% | 2536332.2055 us - 25.044002546143567% |
改变值列编码方式
RLValueEncodingSynExpScripts.sh
编码方式 | GORILLA | PLAIN | RLE | TS_2DIFF |
dataset | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
timeEncoding(te) | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF |
valueDataType(vt) | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 |
valueEncoding(ve) | GORILLA | PLAIN | RLE | TS_2DIFF |
compression(co) | UNCOMPRESSED | UNCOMPRESSED | UNCOMPRESSED | UNCOMPRESSED |
totalPointNum | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 805.3812895 | 781.4226151 | 781.8422318 | 793.3244705 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 80.53803624 | 78.14216614 | 78.18412781 | 79.33235168 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 84386.25189 | 81874 | 81918 | 83122 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 84386.25189 | 81874 | 81918 | 83122 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 82512.25189 | 80000 | 80044 | 81248 |
RLTsFileReadCostBench用法
(1) 用人工数据写TsFile
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar WRITE_SYN [pagePointNum] [numOfPagesInChunk] [chunksWritten] [timeEncoding] [valueDataType] [valueEncoding] [compressionType] |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“写人工数据”
pagePointNum(ppn)
:一个page内的点数numOfPagesInChunk(pic)
:一个chunk内的pages数chunksWritten(cw)
:写的chunks总数timeEncoding(te)
:时间戳列编码方式valueDataType(vt)
:值列数据类型valueEncoding(ve)
:值列编码方式compressionType(co)
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar WRITE_REAL [path_of_real_data_csv_to_write] [pagePointNum] [numOfPagesInChunk] [timeEncoding] [valueDataType] [valueEncoding] [compressionType] |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“写真实数据”
path_of_real_data_csv_to_write
:用来写TsFile的真实数据集csv地址pagePointNum(ppn)
:一个page内的点数numOfPagesInChunk(pic)
:一个chunk内的pages数timeEncoding(te)
:时间戳列编码方式valueDataType(vt)
:值列数据类型valueEncoding(ve)
:值列编码方式compressionType(co)
(3) 读实验
Code Block | ||
---|---|---|
| ||
java -jar RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar READ [path_of_tsfile_to_read] [decomposeMeasureTime] [D_decompose_each_step] (timeEncoding) |
:用来标识是“写人工数据/写真实数据/读数据”中的“读数据”
path_of_tsfile_to_read
:要读取的TsFile地址decomposeMeasureTime
:FALSE
to measure the read process as a whole, in which caseD_decompose_each_step
is useless.TRUE
to measure the decomposed read process, and the decomposition granularity is controlled byD_decompose_each_step
.D_decompose_each_step
:WhendecomposeMeasureTime
isTRUE
,D_decompose_each_step=FALSE
to measure the "(D_1)decompress_pageData" and "(D_2)decode_pageData" steps without further deomposition,D_decompose_each_step=TRUE
to break down these two steps further and measure substeps inside.timeEncoding(te)
:IftimeEncoding
is not specified, TS_2DIFF will be used by default.timeEncoding
...
结合实验目的,
- 目的1:decomposeMeasureTime=TRUE & D_decompose_each_step=FALSE:对比B类操作(磁盘IO代价所在)和D类操作(CPU代价主要所在)耗时
- 目的2:decomposeMeasureTime=TRUE & D_decompose_each_step=TRUE:分析D-1操作内部各子步骤耗时占比,分析D-2操作内部各子步骤耗时占比
自动化脚本
- 输出:一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、一个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
输入:见RLTsFileReadCostBench的写数据参数和读数据参数
输出:一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、一个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
WRITE_READ_JAR_PATH
:RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址Calculator_JAR_PATH
:把若干次重复读实验结果进行平均值和百分比计算的RLRepeatReadResultAvgPercCalculator-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址FILE_NAME
:要读取的TsFile的地址decomposeMeasureTime
:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数D_decompose_each_step
:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数te
::见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数REPEAT
:读实验重复次数
输出:
REPEAT个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件
*readResult-T*csv
一个把重复读实验结果横向拼接起来的csv文件
*readResult-combined.csv
一个把写结果和读结果拼接起来的csv文件
*allResult-combined.csv
一个把读结果取平均值并且按照不同粒度统计百分比的csv文件
工具地址:
WRITE_READ_JAR_PATH
:RLTsFileReadCostBench-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址Calculator_JAR_PATH
:把若干次重复读实验结果进行平均值和百分比统计计算的RLRepeatReadResultAvgPercCalculator-0.13.1-jar-with-dependencies.jar的地址TOOL_PATH
:用于替换脚本中变量值的自动脚本工具RLtool.sh的地址READ_SCRIPT_PATH
:RLReadExpScripts.sh的地址
写数据参数:见RLTsFileReadCostBench写数据参数
读数据参数:见RLTsFileReadCostBench读数据参数
输出:不同压缩方式下的一个TsFile文件、一个TsFile空间统计结果文件(
*writeResult.csv
)、REPEAT个读TsFile耗时结果csv文件(*readResult-T*csv
)、一个把重复读实验结果横向拼接起来的csv文件(*readResult-combined.csv
)、一个把写结果和读结果拼接起来的csv文件(*allResult-combined.csv
)、一个把读结果取平均值并且按照不同粒度统计百分比的csv文件(*allResult-combined-processed.csv
其它类似,不再赘述。
二、实验结果
改变压缩方式
人工数据实验结果
压缩方式 | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
dataset | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic | synthetic |
pagePointNum(ppn) | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 | 10000 |
numOfPagesInChunk(pic) | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 | 1000 |
chunksWritten(cw) | 10 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
timeEncoding(te) | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF | TS_2DIFF |
valueDataType(vt) | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 | INT64 |
valueEncoding(ve) | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN | PLAIN |
compression(co) | GZIP | LZ4 | SNAPPY | UNCOMPRESSED |
totalPointNum | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 | 100000000 |
tsfileSize(MB) | 767.1312866 | 770.8444319 | 767.9423904 | 781.4226151 |
chunkDataSize_stats_mean(MB) | 76.71300761 | 77.08436436 | 76.7941264 | 78.14216614 |
compressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 80375.41867 | 80764.81444 | 80460.47789 | 81874 |
uncompressedPageSize_stats_mean(B) | 81874 | 81874 | 81874 | 81874 |
timeBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 | 1872 |
valueBufferSize_stats_mean(B) | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 | 80000 |
----[1] each step---- | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)1_index_read_deserialize_MagicString_FileMetadataSize(us) | 26642.8733 us - 0.24422388846191903% | 11918.6528 us - 0.16062988779113208% | 10188.2737 us - 0.1309325873262339% | 10953.8906 us - 0.14619657707769018% |
[Avg&Per] (A)2_index_read_deserialize_IndexRootNode_MetaOffset_BloomFilter(us) | 5777.7715 us - 0.05296237408352104% | 5484.9663 us - 0.07392190510886776% | 5140.9507 us - 0.0660679126109081% | 6219.5857 us - 0.08300997092132265% |
[Avg&Per] (A)3_2_index_read_deserialize_IndexRootNode_exclude_to_TimeseriesMetadata_forExactGet(us) | 69234.1118 us - 0.6346396579532295% | 69331.4945 us - 0.9343933722044904% | 67589.2748 us - 0.8686102165735712% | 76722.6646 us - 1.0239823783523703% |
[Avg&Per] (B)4_data_read_deserialize_ChunkHeader(us) | 8684.7625 us - 0.07960952425196037% | 10008.712599999999 us - 0.13488927052826724% | 4487.9059 us - 0.05767543633654741% | 7069.0819 us - 0.09434780888370882% |
[Avg&Per] (B)5_data_read_ChunkData(us) | 5940909.1292 us - 54.457787348789346% | 4839621.4844 us - 65.22447369141621% | 5082130.2731 us - 65.31199351132103% | 4844317.4031 us - 64.65489281142766% |
[Avg&Per] (C)6_data_deserialize_PageHeader(us) | 6613.381399999991 us - 0.060622054656159316% | 7120.158900000014 us - 0.09595969816001626% | 7692.346500000014 us - 0.09885667184764595% | 7605.696300000007 us - 0.10150975630087579% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_data_decompress_PageData(us) | 2859428.0031000106 us - 26.211160404158996% | 521804.2723000004 us - 7.032452670194604% | 605202.8143000009 us - 7.777644443672276% | 498170.42259999976 us - 6.648853201570805% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_data_decode_PageData(us) | 1991910.319299996 us - 18.25899474764487% | 1954657.4198999994 us - 26.343279504596413% | 1998880.5966999987 us - 25.68821922031179% | 2041517.9070999995 us - 27.247207495465567% |
----[2] category: (A)get ChunkStatistic->(B)load on-disk Chunk->(C)get PageStatistics->(D)load in-memory PageData---- | ||||
[Avg&Per] (A)get_chunkMetadatas | 10165491331.7566 98490000001 us - 0.9318259204986696%8580518676474486% | 86735100944.1136 7581 us - 1.1689451651044902%2939556377951902%82918 | 88098.49919999999 20449999999 us - 10.0656107165107132%9671805828234409%93896 | 88231.1409 2157 us - 10.2531889263513831%9257222461823116% |
[Avg&Per] (B)load_on_disk_chunk | 59495935552645.8917000005 935400001 us - 5452.53739687304131%16637107440095% | 48496305170158.197000001 3812 us - 6566.35936296194448%27343223726832%5086618 | 5270914.179 364100001 us - 6557.36966894765757%866400973957255% | 48513865526099.484999999 6186 us - 6457.74924062031137%97985793317826% |
[Avg&Per] (C)get_pageHeader | 66138185.381399999991 805399999992 us - 0.060622054656159316%07690455451459878% | 71207712.158900000014 402700000001 us - 0.09595969816001626%09886107156476356% | 76927813.346500000014 90999999998 us - 0.09885667184764595%08578451820695045% | 76057725.696300000007 986500000003 us - 0.10150975630087579%08106107934716146% |
[Avg&Per] (D_1)decompress_pageData | 2859428548160.0031000106 3352000009 us - 265.211160404158996%149893543905802% | 521804525441.2723000004 0348000005 us - 76.032452670194604%7353412114264035%605202 | 585036.8143000009 2351000007 us - 76.777644443672276%422783415941812% | 498170632154.42259999976 6457000006 us - 6.648853201570805%632568914631739% |
[Avg&Per] (D_2)decode_pageData | 19919104443785.319299996 968300003 us - 1841.25899474764487%748778959531215% | 19546571996996.4198999994 816400002 us - 2625.343279504596413%598409841945312%1998880 | 3156902.5966999987 088299994 us - 2534.68821922031179%65785050907054% | 20415173276856.9070999995 417400001 us - 2734.247207495465567%38078982666053% |
----[3] D_1 compare each step inside---- | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_1_data_ByteBuffer_to_ByteArray(us) | 65952110421.37819999998 72189999989 us - 264.5136549346918415%93156378407389% | 108809109687.34350000018 91739999971 us - 5963.6896105506002%92643734398307% | 108132113658.35939999981 35759999987 us - 4362.622622294156905%901942587101885% | 110765109187.11740000003 47799999996 us - 63.813731447511664%08420663361515% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_2_data_decompress_PageDataByteArray(us) | 255468754624.926599999 26410000002 us - 9732.36728361519128%12084386602246% | 6890457095.38600000006 555900000094 us - 3733.79892271446546%27545607007074% | 13534562164.91170000008 880499999985 us - 5434.601079805416944%403908579311135% | 5754759072.215800000035 25890000005 us - 3334.15396273496119%12961499817788% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_3_data_ByteArray_to_ByteBuffer(us) | 8111179.8335000000624 3427000000347 us - 0.03094155721322126%6934918640164246% | 12391234.949800000022 10400000004 us - 0.680200047933345%7192394012210651% | 11841032.7460000000272 115900000022 us - 0.47794876167766753%5712038820191121% | 12291193.1439000000355 2719000000652 us - 0.7081314098345313%6894253122110825% |
[Avg&Per] (D-1)7_4_data_split_time_value_Buffer(us) | 23123833.0582000000422 2921999999994 us - 02.08811989290364733%254100485887217% | 33383567.2513999999974 0158000000133 us - 12.8312666870009688%0788671847251163%3218 | 3835.3657999999955 9775000000177 us - 12.29834913874849%122944951567873% | 40343629.201500000018 1045000000054 us - 2.3241744076926314%0967530559958814% |
----[3] D_2 compare each step inside---- | ||||
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_1_createBatchData(us) | 53846008.7852 9294 us - 0.053292019060348375%04720551599260821% | 58486005.7599 094 us - 0.05759123169122766%058953749593284185% | 59139136.4963 1988 us - 0.058362326692940975%07959246314858166% | 60196219.3023 250599999999 us - 0.05943520403215091%053213386787106826% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_2_timeDecoder_hasNext(us) | 18598421795067.2956 4479 us - 1814.406444711361424%10186066084482% | 18622341862631.7849 8749 us - 18.336946086748988%285997377780266%1864092 | 1805100.3926 2815999999 us - 1815.397368271414525%725618584694368%1857778 | 1838661.6739 8702 us - 1815.343895858133802%732028111177547% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_3_timeDecoder_readLong(us) | 20747572073615.7936 2138 us - 2016.533415498567617%290102549307967% | 20847002089493.4377 8765 us - 20.527508047369906%513167449482335%2063043 | 2063469.8916 3846 us - 2017.360888969091857%976470800088325%2069930 | 2172029.4964 5514 us - 2018.43870456313607%58440125112089% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_4_valueDecoder_read(us) | 18760124636195.952 4124 us - 1836.56648209392724%42146247963989% | 18814711880348.5433999998 902 us - 18.526365490982297%459930571697104%1877809 | 3352494.2412 9242 us - 1829.532744562964893%206164899804453%1876843 | 3364558.1276 2458 us - 1828.53214021585961%787960289219587% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_5_checkValueSatisfyOrNot(us) | 17803791724239.6374 435 us - 1713.620020492363725%545443257159627% | 17807821784205.3133 2864 us - 17.534904586680103%516060810611705%1781949 | 1723128.2049 802 us - 1715.586668929952697%01150190311584%1780599 | 1780807.5789 3196 us - 1715.5818216126948%237010821076382% |
[Avg&Per] (D-2)8_6_putIntoBatchData(us) | 25079222494168.0072 5891 us - 2419.82034518471963%59392553705509% | 25406052563425.1784 3348 us - 25.016684556527476%165890040835308%2539577 | 2525393.912 9444 us - 2522.063966939883077%000651349148434%2536332 | 2525103.2055 5280999998 us - 25.044002546143567% |
改变编码方式
人工数据实验结果
...
21.605386140618513% |